Thursday, October 02, 2014

A Climate Change Non-Event

Indian Prime Minister Modi in his visit to the US, at the event at Madison Square Garden, at the Council for Foreign Relations, at the United Nations General Assembly spoke repeatedly of the crisis that climate change is bringing upon the planet, and of his plans for clean energy for India.  He has the slogan "zero defect, zero effect" for manufacturing in India - i.e., Indian manufacturing will try to be world class and try to have zero net effect on the environment.

Strange that this has received next to zero coverage in the US media and blogs. 

If you estimate the sustainable rate of carbon dioxide emission (so that CO2 concentration remains constant) for the planet, and divide it by the world population, you get a per capita carbon budget (tons of CO2 per person per year).

Two important observations:
  1. Indians as of 2007 were well below this per capita limit.
  2. 1250 million Indians want to industrialize and fast (that is why they voted for Modi).
 So what India is able to do is crucial to the future of the planet's climate.

When the Indian Prime Minister Modi comes to the US and talks about climate change, and his aspiration to industrialize in a carbon-neutral way, and the US media collectively gives a yawn, it is infinitely and amply clear, that climate change is not taken seriously here, even in the liberal section of the media. When a key player in the world's carbon dioxide economy lands on their shores, and talks planet-friendly, it is a non-event.

Conclusion: Climate change doesn't exist for the Republicans; and for the Democrats, it is merely a way to bash Republicans as anti-science. 







Comments (5)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
The Gardener's avatar

The Gardener · 545 weeks ago

Isn't it a fact that the so-called 'developed' nations have a greater share of carbon-emission?
1 reply · active 545 weeks ago
Very much so, both in per-capita and in absolute terms. India is not high per-capita, but because of the huge population, is an overall large contributor.
To industrialize in a carbon neutral way is a great ambition, but the achievement will be difficult. If India succeeds, it will be a model for the world.
1 reply · active 545 weeks ago
To industrialize in a carbon neutral way certainly is aspirational rather than definite plan. To do so will require the help of the world, in developing and perfecting new technologies. That is why I was hoping Modi got some American attention.
Modi's statements may not have caught the 'center of gravity' of the attention of the either US political grouping, I think any actual, significant innovation in policies and actions would be almost immediately noted by important actors in US academia and industry.

My personal impression is that both the Democrats and (especially) the Republicans are currently defocused from serious action that's required even to boost the US economy, so paying attention to India and Modi is certainly not in their attention-zone.

Post a new comment

Comments by